Install New Handles Before Painting Cabinets: Why Skipping This Step Could Ruin Your Project
Let me start with a story. Last year, a friend decided to refresh her kitchen cabinets. She painted them a gorgeous sage green, reinstalled her old handles… and immediately noticed chips around the screw holes. Why? She hadn’t considered installing new handles before painting cabinets. The result? A week of touch-ups and frustration.
As Nick May from Walls by Design explains, this step isn’t just a “nice-to-have”—it’s a game-changer. Let’s dive into why pros like him swear by this method (and why you should too).
Not Everyone Needs New Handles… But Here’s Why It’s Worth Considering
First things first: installing new handles before painting cabinets isn’t mandatory. If your existing hardware works, you can reuse it! But here’s the kicker: even if you think your new handles match your old ones, they might not.
Nick puts it bluntly: “Go ahead—buy those ‘standard’ handles. But test-fit them first.” Why? Many so-called “standard” handles are off by as little as 1/8 inch. That tiny discrepancy can leave handles crooked or force you to redrill holes after painting—risking damage to your fresh finish.
The Hidden Cost of “I’ll Fix It Later”
Imagine the following possible scenario:
You paint your cabinets.
You install new handles… only to find they don’t align.
You drill new holes, chipping the paint.
Now you’re repainting doors or drawers.
Sound exhausting? That’s why installing new handles before painting cabinets saves time, money, and sanity. As Nick says, “It’s like measuring twice and cutting once. Drill first, paint once.”
Why Pros Drill First, Paint Second
Let’s break down the process Walls by Design uses:
Test-Fit New Handles: Even “identical” replacements can differ. Test before committing!
Drill Correct Holes: If adjustments are needed, drilling before painting avoids touch-ups.
Paint with Confidence: No stress about post-paint surprises.
This isn’t just about perfection—it’s about efficiency. Nick notes, “We’d rather spend an extra hour prepping than days fixing mistakes.”
“But What If I Reuse My Old Handles?”
Great question! If your existing hardware fits and you love it, reuse it! The key is removing handles before painting. This lets you:
Avoid paint buildup around edges.
Ensure smooth, even coverage.
Reinstall hardware seamlessly.
Pro Tip: Label handles and screws with painter’s tape to avoid mix-ups.
The #1 Mistake DIYers Make
Spoiler: It’s impatience. Skipping the install new handles before painting cabinets step to “save time” often backfires. I’ve seen clients try to eyeball measurements, only to end up with misaligned handles and a splotchy finish.
As Nick warns, “If you paint first and drill later, you’re gambling. And the house usually wins.”
How to Choose the Right Handles
Struggling to pick hardware? Here’s a quick guide:
Modern Look: Sleek bar pulls (check out Home Depot’s selection).
Classic Vibes: Cup pulls or bin handles.
Mixed Metals: Match finishes to faucets or lighting.
For more tips, explore our guide: How to Choose Cabinet Hardware That Elevates Your Kitchen.
Final Thoughts
Installing new handles before painting cabinets might feel like an extra step, but trust me—it’s a lifesaver. Whether you’re a DIY warrior or hiring pros like Walls by Design, this method guarantees a polished, professional result.
Still on the fence? Grab your handles, test-fit them, and see for yourself. Your future self (and your cabinets) will thank you.